Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves, not looking to your own interests but each of you to the interests of the others. (Philippians 2:3-4)
When I was coming of age in the 1970s, Pass It On was a popular youth campfire song. Some teens learned to play guitar because of that song. The first YouTube version which popped up in my search even has a fire burning in the background. If any Christian song can date my generation, this one might be it:
It only takes a spark to get a fire going,
And soon all those around will warm up in its glowing.
That’s how it is with God’s love, once you’ve experienced it,
You spread His love to ev’ryone; You want to pass it on.
In the five decades since Kurt Kaiser wrote those iconic lyrics (in just 20 minutes), the preeminent goal of my life has been to pass on the love of Jesus Christ. Seeds which flourished in my pastoral ministry were planted in the commitment of that song and the experience of singing it at camp. The song bore fruit even though the guitar playing was often terrible. I still want to pass it on.
What do we do at New Life Church? We pass it on. Our mission is to help people know Jesus.
During the coronavirus pandemic crisis, our mission has not changed. But how we carry out our mission has changed. As we prepare for the reopening stage of the coronavirus pandemic, health concerns are a very high priority. We seek a COVID-free environment at church. At least, as much as possible.
The process is not easy. It begins with valuing others above ourselves, as the Apostle Paul wrote to the Philippians. My private mantra has become that every person has the right and the responsibility to determine his or her own level of risk. But nobody has the right to carelessly or presumptuously pass the virus on to others. Everyone must establish their personal risk tolerance, based on their age, their health, their job, their environment and their fears. But no one benefits when we transmit the virus to others. The result could be devastating, especially in a community of older and vulnerable people.
There is tension between our mission and our method. What do we do at New Life Church? We pass it on while we don’t pass it on. That’s why we have been meeting remotely for the past several weeks. Now that the world has begun to relax, a few people have asked for my criteria about reopening the church. I have three thoughts:
1) We should reopen the church when we can carry out our mission more effectively than meeting remotely. In a perfect world, we would always meet face to face. Personal contact is at the heart of the gospel. Jesus came from heaven to meet humanity face to face. I was taught in Greek class that being “with” God or “with” one another literally means “face to face.” Nothing can substitute for personal contact.
COVID-19 has changed the way we do personal contact. Surprisingly, we have discovered some new strengths. At New Life Church, people have joined us from four states in our Zoom virtual worship meetings. We will lose some of those connections when we reopen the church. We found there’s a price to pay for meeting remotely. We’ll find there’s a price to pay when we reopen, too. For a season, the best way to love our neighbor has been to stay home and not get sick. As that window closes, we must evaluate about how opening the church would affect our witness in the community. If we lose more in community good will than we gain in physical fellowship, the price of reopening is still too high. My top concern is not our constitutional right to meet or our familiar desire to gather as a church body; it’s the welfare of our neighbors. Moving to the next stage of the coronavirus crisis does not override our mandated priority of putting others first.
Furthermore, when we do open, some members may not return to church because of the inherent health risks in group settings. Maybe a new form of ministry will evolve in which the church can meet physically and remotely at the same time. Many churches have been doing that effectively for years. Perhaps it’s our turn now.
2) We should reopen the church when we can meet the CDC’s guidelines for safety. Specifically, that would require two weeks of decline in new positive virus cases along with the capacity of the medical community to test everyone for tracking purposes. These standards are necessary for containment in the event of a new wave of COVID cases.
In addition, the governor is providing criteria for reopening churches. I will listen carefully and observe any restrictions and guidelines which apply to us.
As I write, Minnesota has experienced a small surge in cases after a brief downturn, including our area. Today’s death toll was the highest yet. Testing has increased, but it’s still not as widespread as will be necessary to contain a new outbreak. Many places are reopening despite not meeting CDC guidelines. Nationally, behavioral norms have shifted away from social distancing in the past few weeks. Therefore, the CDC guidelines may become goals to achieve after reopening instead of being a prerequisite to fulfill before reopening.
3) We should reopen the church only after the leadership team has planned and executed appropriate safety measures and ministry adjustments. The national office of the C&MA recently released a relaunch planning guide with excellent questions for church leaders. Of the several dozen questions, I circled thirteen items of special interest to me. Our leadership team may not be able to discuss all of them, but we should hit the critical ones, at least. It’s not enough to want to return to normal. We need patience planning, not impatient pouting. Here are my top five questions in the order in which they appear on the list:
#8 – When will we allow the relaunch of small groups meeting in person, and what precautionary steps will they need to take?
#12 – How will we suggest that people greet one another? Should handshakes and hugs be avoided for the initial season of relaunch?
#14 – What surfaces will need extra cleaning during this time to help ensure people’s safety? How will we accommodate this need?
#20 – Is our website and social media presence adequate for the times in which we live? What did we learn about this during the crisis that has ongoing application?
#22 – Would it be wise to continue providing the Sunday worship experience in some sort of online fashion (livestream or recorded) for the vulnerable, for those who may not be ready to be in a group of people, and as an outreach tool?